Privacy does not exist in our time, with so many different types of technology it makes complete privacy difficult to achieve. Even though we seem to care about our privacy everyone seems to need some type of technology that can locate where they are on maps or publish their personalities for the world to see online. The media is another example of our need for information. Magazines and TV shows base all of their topics on what celebrities are doing. The movie, State of Play, is a prime example of invasion of privacy. Each person in this film is searching deeper and deeper for more information about these two sets of murders. An example of the invasion of privacy in this movie is when two of the reporters are in the hotel rooms interviewing someone and in the other room there is a video and audio equipment to capture everything the interview includes. Privacy is unattainable in today’s society and it is such a big role in our society that it seems impossible to change.
Friday, November 12, 2010
Lighter - State of Play
Privacy does not exist in our time, with so many different types of technology it makes complete privacy difficult to achieve. Even though we seem to care about our privacy everyone seems to need some type of technology that can locate where they are on maps or publish their personalities for the world to see online. The media is another example of our need for information. Magazines and TV shows base all of their topics on what celebrities are doing. The movie, State of Play, is a prime example of invasion of privacy. Each person in this film is searching deeper and deeper for more information about these two sets of murders. An example of the invasion of privacy in this movie is when two of the reporters are in the hotel rooms interviewing someone and in the other room there is a video and audio equipment to capture everything the interview includes. Privacy is unattainable in today’s society and it is such a big role in our society that it seems impossible to change.
Calderon State of Play
Privacy is an issue that any democracy has to deal with, but it is essential to have privacy in order for the democracy to flourish. There cannot be people all over the United States knowing about everyone else's business. That would make democracy to powerful and it would be corrupt. An example from the movie would be when the newspaper finds out who the shooter was and why he was after the pizza delivery boy. Cal and Della go to visit the pizza delivery boy, but Della is there to witness the shooter murder the pizza delivery boy. The fact that the newspaper was witholding information from the police is corrupt because they were using private information for their own personal gain. That in essence is corrupting the privacy of individuals. They is no way to trust anyone with private information if in fact they are using it for their own personal gain. It is too much information to trust with just anyone. The foundation of the country is based on freedom and if the government tries to control privacy then it is actually going against what the founding fathers wanted. In all essence, privacy is needed and without it our government would be too corrupt.
Whitlock State of Play
I think that privacy is necessary for democracy to flourish because the United States is founded on allowing its citizens to have freedom. If America becomes Big Brother and watches everything that a person does then the foundation that the U.S. was built on will crumble. Politicians also deserve this same privacy. A scene in the movie where this made clear is when Collins is at the press conference and breaks down crying after he finds out that Sonya has died. Immediately the press has a field day and rumors begin to swirl that he has had an affair with this woman. Just because of this affair, his whole image is completely destroyed and now he will be a household name because he cheated, not because of the things that he was able to do for his country. He fought in the army and helped pass laws as a congressman but now he is only known as a cheater.
McGowan State of Play
The reasons that democracy is so dependent are obvious. Democracy is based on people being entitled to their own opinion, and the ability to voice that opinion. How could someone actually have an opinion that counts if they are being watched by cameras and having their phone calls listened in on? This loss of privacy can cause people to change their opinions based on what they think would please the government. Our society has become much too centered around the fear of pissing off the government, while it should easily be the other way around. A democracy should be able to please its people, not watch them, not analyze them. It is impossible for a citizen to voice their opinion if they are living in the fear of what the government may think of that opinion. I think that this new technology has cause too many people to "change" their opinions in order to please others. It is absolutely ridiculous that we have thrown our individuality away because a few cameras and some satellites.
Leary State of Play
In the movie, State of Play, it definitely shows how necessary privacy is for a democracy to grow. A democracy is supposed to be a government ruled by the people, for the people. Without privacy for the people, it wouldn’t be a democracy because it would be going against the people and what is best for the people. Privacy is something that we as citizens are entitled to and if we don’t get that privacy that we deserve then many things would go wrong and this democracy would fall apart.
One scene in the movie that really supports this idea is the scene towards the end of the movie when Collins is telling his side of the story to the reporters. It starts out with the tape recorder being turned on and a mirror image of Collins in the table. This is showing that they are about to record Collins’ side of the story which is a loss of privacy because they are in a way pressuring him to be recorded and to use his words for the world to know what he has done in his personal life. Next, Collins starts to tell the story while it zooms in on his face and there is a shadow casted across his face. This could represent the situation that Collins was in where there is both a dark and innocent side to his story. The dark side being where he was cheated on his wife, and the innocent side where he actually got played in the end by Sonya. The camera then goes around the whole table, zooming in on each individual face in order to get a sense of closeness to the characters and feel how each of them relate to Collins story. In the middle of his story, the camera cuts to a different scene where Robert Bingham is putting on his army uniform and assembling his gun. He does everything very slowly and makes sure everything is perfect. While you see him getting ready, Collins is still telling his story except now his sentences are getting cut off early. Each sentence he says is about how privacy was being violated with everything that has happened in this situation. I think this is a very important part in the scene because it shows that since so many people had their privacy taken away from them, information that was never suppose to be uncovered was found out and multiple people got killed or hurt throughout this. The only reason innocent people were killed was because there was a loss of privacy where if someone knew something then they had to be killed. This would have never happened if this story hadn’t of dragged on to the point that so much unknown information had to be uncovered to find out the truth.
This is why I think privacy is necessary for a democracy to flourish. If we had no privacy like how no one in this film had privacy, then our democracy would fall and many people would get killed, just like what also happened in this film. This is a great example of what could happen to us if we let our privacy be taken from us.