Showing posts with label joseph mccarthy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label joseph mccarthy. Show all posts

Saturday, October 9, 2010

Curtis WMDs and Communism



“Intelligence gathered by this and other governments leaves no doubt that the Iraq regime continues to possess and conceal some of the most lethal weapons ever devised.” – George W. Bush. Sure, W. The United States government in the year 2005 was just as out of line with their accusation of Iraq concealing weapons of mass destruction as Senator Joseph McCarthy was with accusing people of being communists. Obviously, George Clooney was trying to illustrate this with his directorial debut Goodnight and Good Luck.

In 2005, we could prove nothing, just as McCarthy had no proof that those he accused of being communist were actually communist in 1963. What happened in both situations is the government found a common enemy for society in both times, and exploited them. In times of despair and lack of hope Americans want someone to blame. Jumping on the coat tails of the Soviet Union in the 50s and the animosity towards Middle Eastern countries after 9/11. The timing of the release of Goodnight and Good Luck clearly had to do with the fact that George Clooney wanted to make a statement: our government is full of loons. The movie examines how the media responded to McCarthy, objecting to and challenging his claims. Evidently, Clooney believes that Bush’s claims were just as fallacious, or else the subject matter of this film would be quite different.

There’s a simple way to sum up Goodnight and Good Luck: No physical evidence? No need to speak, boys.

Roulakis - Good Night and Good Luck


Was George W. Bush just as out of line with his “weapons of mass destruction” as Senator McCarthy was with accusing people of being communists? I think Goodnight and Good Luck was trying to ask that question. In 2005, we didn’t actually know for sure whether or not any of the countries we were accusing of having these weapons actually had them. The same thing happened in 2005. McCarthy found an enemy that everyone could hate and created this paranoid mindset that most Americans could relate to. The enemy in the 50’s was the Soviet Union, and the enemy that was created shortly after 9/11 was Iraq.

George Clooney must have very intentionally released this movie two years after our invasion of Iraq. This point could probably be defended, but the timing of the movie makes it seem as though he wanted to make a point that Bush was being as crazy as McCarthy by using this phrase. The entire movie is about these journalists trying to prove how McCarthy’s fear tactic is unjust, and I think Clooney was trying to hint that Bush’s was as well.

Leary-Good Night and Good Luck

Three cinematic techniques used in Good Night and Good Luck that really caught my attention were black and white photography, close up shots/tight frames, and all the indoor shots. Personally, I think it was a great idea to film the movie in black and white because it makes the audience feel more like they are actually in 1953, watching this as it is happening. If the movie was in color, I feel like it wouldn’t seem as realistic and would make you feel like you are just watching what happened back then which isn’t as exciting as watching an event as it occurs. The black and white photography also seems to say that this movie is actually “black and white”, meaning that McCarthy is black because he is doing wrong and Murrow is white because he is doing what is right. McCarthy is doing wrong in this movie by accusing innocent people of being communists when he has no actual proof. Murrow and the news crew are doing the right thing by standing up to McCarthy when no one else will and showing the viewers why/how what he is doing is wrong. Black and white photography seemed to really make the movie. It actually made me more alert to what was going on in the movie because since black and white seems boring and dull, the message the movie is trying to make really stands out.

The second cinematic technique I chose was how this movie has a lot of close up shots and tight frames. Every time the camera zooms in on a persons face, you actually feel like you are right in front of that person, actually talking to them, which makes it so much more personal. It makes the audience feel like they are dealing with the conflict with the person whose face is zoomed in on. Each time the camera does a close up, it seems to also have a tight frame. This tight framing shows that whoever is zoomed in on is in a very tight position and doesn’t have much room to move. I saw many tight frames where the person was in a very difficult situation where they didn’t really know what they should do and what was right or wrong (black and white). I think using tight framing was a very smart idea that also made the audience feel the stress that the characters were feeling which made the movie very relatable.

The last technique I chose was the indoor shots. The shots in this movie were all indoor shots that were pretty much all in the television-recording studio. The indoor shots make the characters in the movie seem trapped in one area. These shots also make the characters not have much room to move since they are taking on such a serious issue that will affect everyone watching their television show. Since they are never outside, it may seem like they will never see daylight. What I mean by this is that they are trapped indoors with the communist issue and since the shots are never outside, they might never see the sunlight as in happiness or peace. This relates to the plot of the movie because the characters are taking on a very serious issue that the characters feel troubled by. I think the indoor shots were a very good, creative idea. I would of never thought about the relationship between the shots being in doors and the struggle for room to move. It is a very interesting idea that makes the movie even better.

Overall, I believe that all three of these cinematic techniques were great ideas that helped the movie prove its point. All of these techniques sent out the message that Murrow and the television crew were trying to do what was right but ended up with tough decisions that trapped them between what is right and what is wrong.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

del Valle, Good Night, and Good Luck

“His primary achievement has been in confusing the public mind, as between internal and the external threats of Communism. We must not confuse dissent (opposition) with disloyalty. We must remember always that accusation is not proof and that conviction depends upon evidence and due process of law. We will not walk in fear, one of another. We will not be driven by fear into an age of unreason, if we dig deep in our history and our doctrine, and remember that we are not descended from fearful men -- not from men who feared to write, to speak, to associate and to defend causes that were, for the moment, unpopular." (“Of Murrow, McCarthy & Miller” by Jim Emerson)

In the film, Good Night, and Good Luck, there are many uncertainties surrounding Joseph McCarthy and his approach towards “ridding the country of communism”, that are pointed out in newscasts by the reporter Edward R. Murrow. Joseph McCarthy attempted to gain the support of the country through propaganda, “half-truths”, and some “outright lies”. For example, he had claimed that the American Civil Liberties Union was reported as a Communist Party in disguise, however he was never able to state who had reported the group as this, in fact, there was evidence proving this group as the opposite, as a group known to never have been reported as dissident. McCarthy used lies to not only persuade the country, but to also confuse them into consent, convincing them that those being prosecuted were threats to the country in their loyalty to communism and disloyalty to America. He also had a way of confusing disloyalty with disagreement. He seemed to forget that in our country that all people are innocent until proven guilty. Similarly, in 2005, there was skepticism revolving the Bush and Cheney administration and their choice to begin a war with Iraq. The basis of their choice was evidence they claimed to have that proved that there were Weapons of Mass Destruction being made in the country. However, similar to the way McCarthy’s accusations were always just that, and not based on actual facts or evidence, but instead based more in falsehoods, the “discovery” of the weapons, also, was just an accusation, and when further investigated was in fact proven to be false. However, the government continued on their track, insisting the evidence, which had been falsified, still gave reason to start the invasions and wars. McCarthy’s accusations has more evidence opposing his beliefs, however he carried on with his persecutions, similarly the administration in 2005, did the same. When Cheney received documents from the British, from the Italiams, claiming to confirm Iraq’s purchase of uranium of Niger, the CIA was notified and called for a further investigation of the situation, when the investigation was complete, it was verified that the documents were forged, however, the administration still referred to these documents as a form of validation or as a motive for their actions.

Considering the similarity of the two situations, I think Edward R. Murrow would be successful had he taken the same approach in 2005 that he did in 1953. I don’t think it would happen right away, however, I think, through a few steps, he would gain the support of the country. Through presenting the public with the facts, based on evidence, that would prove the government was lying, he would raise doubts in the public, and therefore make them question the administration. Then through his persistence in presenting these truths, he would eventually persuade, some, and possibly all of the public, to see the truth. Finally, he would gain their full support when pointing out things such as how the government is hurting the public in their decisions, creating a “common enemy”, and then by pointing out that our country was based on the idea that everyone is innocent until proven guilty, and without proper evidence supporting otherwise, those being attacked are not guilty.