Friday, November 5, 2010

Lanaux American History X


The scene that illustrates the attractiveness of Nazism/Facism to a group of young people is the scene right before the vandalism of the Korean owned store. We see Derek rallying a group of young skinheads while Danny explains the reason for the increasing following Derek garners. Danny says the new skinheads are young men who have been harassed and beaten by black thugs. In the words of Danny, 'Don't just be some punk, be part of something." They manifest their fear and frustration into extreme prejudice for the sake of power and revenge.

Later in the scene we see Derek preaching to the eager new members his neo-nazi propaganda. The camera focuses on him through most of his speech but we get brief shots of various members watching him. The shots of them are in close up, and we see that they are fully attentive and absorbing the material. The camera focuses on Derek longer though so we the audience can pay attention to everything he is saying. The shot looks as if we're a part of the crowd. The article on white supremacy talks about the issue of voice and how the choice of giving Derek various opportunities to preach makes a difference in the message to viewers take from the film. The article states the white supremacist is the brightest and most articulate and the other side are to meek and ignorant to argue. While I disagree that the opposing side of Derek's views are not as smart, I agree that having Derek be the most articulate character is an important aspect of the film. It makes his personal transformation much more meaningful.

Calderon American History X Young People


Fascism/Nazism was attractive to the young people of Venice Beach in California. It attracted the young people that were once scared of the black gangs taking over the neighborhoods. There is a scene where Danny talks about the gangs as if they were a “plague” coming to take over everyone in the neighborhood. It is when Derek gave him the idea that white kids shouldn’t walk scared of black kids in their own neighborhood. It is exactly why Derek started the whole deal to win the basketball court back over to the whites of the neighborhood. The exact scene Danny talks about the whole idea is a very personal shot of his face when making a smirk to the black boy he had smoked right in front of in the bathroom. It is when he comes to the basketball court to tell about the old days at the basketball court. It’s as if Danny wants the black boys to think there are coming sooner or later so they better watch out. It is a personal shot to show emotion in Danny’s face about how he felt superior to the blacks in the neighborhood even though Derek was in jail. He recalls the old days when Derek won the basketball court. It shows specifically the class of young people Fascism and racism attracted because those are the white young people wanting to get rid of the blacks in the neighborhood. Just as stated in the article, the most stereotypical form of black people depicted in the movie are violent thugs and Derek wanted to get rid of these violent thugs to make sure the white kids would not be scared in their own neighborhood. They are violently depicted in the basketball when Derek is playing fair and winning, then one of the black guys has to come up and hit him. Derek specifically in the basketball scene shows his white superiority and it is those type of young people that are attracted to the Fascism/Nazism ideas. Derek would feed the kids ideas that the black people needed to go and it would be done in an easy fair way. The basketball court scene shows Derek’s perfect idea and the black and white filming shows exactly how Derek viewed the world for himself. It was as simple as black and white.

Palmer American History X



The most prominent scene that illustrates the attractiveness of Facism/Nazism is when Derek leads an impassioned speech to a group of young white kids. Here, Derek expresses why they should be frustrated and angry with the other people in the area, primarily the Black, Korean, and Mexican people. In regards to the article, Derek portrays the white people as being victims in their neighborhood. They are at a disadvantage because of their race. We see him instill this passion for hating the other people into these confused teenagers.

Regarding mise en scene, one can begin to analyze framing and spacing of the scene. The frame turns extremely tight as soon as Derek begins talking. We are not allowed to see the entire group in one frame. The majority of the screen time is devoted to Derek once he begins talking. We get brief looks at the remaining characters in order to gauge their reaction to Derek's speech. Throughout most of the scene, Derek remains in the center and when other characters enter the scene, he is above them in stature which makes him the dominant. This is necessary to project his radical racist views as dominating the others. The spacing only reinforces Derek's dominance. He is never extremely close to any of the other characters. Furthermore, he remains the center of attention, because he is in the center of the group throughout his speech. This forces the characters and viewers to bring their attention to him. When we consider all of this, we can safely assume that the scene was constructed this way in order to perpetuated the dominance of this white supremacy idea that Derek was the embodiment of.

Nguyen American History X




The most noted scene that expresses Fascism and Nazism propaganda is when Cameron sent Derek to the kids that felt out of placed, neglected, and always getting beaten, mainly by the blacks and Mexicans. Derek would feed the kids information about minorities that would skew their minds of the white kids into believing anything Derek said and do anything he told them too. Derek’s followers do not have anywhere else to go or let out their frustration. This gang makes them feel like they are a part of something. As a pact, they are less likely to be picked on and, if they are bullied, they are stronger as a group. Within the group, they form friendships that are created through a common belief based on white supremacy. The group acts out on these beliefs by causing vandalism and minor crimes. In this scene specifically, Derek and his new members vandalize a Korean owned market.

The scene of Derek recruiting the white people is filmed in black and white because that is how these people saw the world. What was not white was not acceptable through their eyes. The lighting is dark in this scene as well because it is during the night. The darkness also shows how convoluted the minds of these kids and younger adults really are. Their beliefs and social situation express ignorance to their surroundings. They are unable to realize the importance of others. The close proxemics displays a close relationship between Derek, the group, and how they share a simple mindset of Nazism. Derek immediately grabs the audience’s attention with his white supremacy propaganda. This establishes exactly how serious his views are.

In the article, it talks about how Derek was already forming some racial beliefs before meeting Cameron. In the movie, it is learned that the reason these beliefs were forming was because of his father who planted the seed for his racial ways of looking at the world. Black stereotypes are expressed in the article as a major recurrence within many “anti-racial” movies. Although the hero overcomes his ignorance, the movie is filled with blacks with stereotypical characteristics and situations. However, the stereotypes mentioned in the article are placed to give the movie a more racial aspect. After all,it is a movie about racism.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Turner American History X































American History X makes Facism/Nazism attractive to white, lower-class, bullied, confused, and usually male, teens. The white supremacists groups offer these young impressionable teens protection and friends. In these groups they feel a sense of community and belonging. The group’s views become their own because they want to be a part of something and they look up to their fellow members who treat them well and with respect. The scene that best illustrates why this type of young people is attracted to Nazism is the one where the group of white supremacist neo-Nazis are about to vandalize and destroy the Korean-owned grocery store.

The group of white supremacist gathers in the parking lot around Derek. He is dominant in the scene and so he is viewed as the important character and gets the majority of the face time. Character placement is important in the scene. Derek is in front while his girlfriend and Danny are behind him, obviously supporting what he’s saying. Everyone else is surrounding Derek. Derek starts to talk and tells the group around him why they are taking action on the store. Everyone is looking at him and the camera shows close ups of some of the members listening intently and agreeing with him. Derek is young, buff, and manly, and could be viewed as an embodiment of white hyper masculinity. His speech is intelligent sounding and he makes points that could be convincing to certain people. The group is working together to accomplish something and even though that something is horrendous, this specific comradely may be attractive to certain young people.

The article states that “the loudest, longest, and most passionate voice or opportunity to speak makes a difference in the messages that viewers take from a film” and that “the white supremacist characters are clearly given more opportunities for unrefuted diatribes than the opposition.” This particular scene supports this idea, but I think that Derek’s views and what he says in this scene and throughout the movie are obviously ridiculous and so blatantly wrong that a viewer could not possibly take a racist message from the film.

Thompson American History X


American History X is a movie on how changes in society can shape a community of young people. White youth of L.A come together to be apart of the white supremacist neo-Nazi movement. Danny Vineyard states; “frustrated kids, the ones who were sick of getting their asses kicked by the black and Mexican gangs. don’t just be some punk, be a part of something.” Alone, scared, and frustrated youth, all experiencing the same problems with the minority of America; African-Americans, Koreans, Latinos, and Arabs.These youth are afraid of walking in their own neighborhood, even going to their school in fear of getting jumped by African-Americans. Being apart of something gives the children a sense of belonging and acceptance to their feelings of the minority and immigrants. The scene that can support my statement is where Derek is preaching to the young neo-Nazis. He gives manipulative reason as to why immigrants and anyone who is not white should be prosecuted and kept out of the United States. Desperate, ignorant and weak-minded white youth believe and do anything that Derek says.

The scene is in black and white. This eliminates all color and individuality. All we can see is their shaven head all looking at Derek. By only seeing their head, we can only see neo-Nazis because all of the children look just like Derek. This shows Derek as the leader and the influence of the group. But never mind the children playing the part of the follower, being alone is more scary than having no identity and being invisible.
The staging placement of Derek is profile. Derek being that of profile shows him being lost in his own thoughts. This makes the viewer question who is Derek really trying to persuade in the group; is it him or the youth? Talking and babbling on about the neo-Nazi movement and their beliefs maybe a way of reiterating the thoughts into his mind as while as others.
One section in the article speaks of how in American History X, Derek is seen more as pro-white and patriotic and less of the stereotypical redneck racist and anti-back white. With Derek articulate explanations of the reason why America is like it is, he is seen in a more modern stereotype of a redneck racist.

McElvaine American History X


In the film, American History X, Neo-Nazism is made attractive to lower middle class white Americans who are angry and looking for someone to blame for all of their hardships. Cameron, the leader of the Neo-Nazi group in the film, simply gives these young people an outlet to express their anger. A scene that very clearly portrays what type of people Cameron is targeting is the scene in which Derek goes to a party at Cameron's house to inform him that he no longer wants anything to do with the gang. Derek states that Cameron coerces people into joining his movement by "preying" on them. Derek means that Cameron seeks out people who are feeling weak, insecure, and confused and gives them a cause for which to fight, a place to put the blame for how they feel. In this scene, Derek returns to remove himself from the group and the scene serves to portray what type of world Derek is trying to escape. For most of the scene, Cameron in filmed with a Swastika flag behind his back. The room where the the scene takes place is also filled with White Power propaganda and pictures of Hitler. The scene traps Derek in this world of Neo-Nazism that he is trying to free himself from. The entrapment of Derek shows how powerful the constraints of the beliefs of the Neo-Nazi movement are and how difficult they are to escape. Derek's struggle to escape is taken one step further when he is trying to leave the party and he is met with a chaotic scene of skin heads surrounding him and calling him a Nigger. All of the people who are screaming at Derek are immensely angry and hostile which speaks to the type of person Cameron is targeting. He manipulates people's anger into something he can control and s
teer in any direction he chooses.