Thursday, November 4, 2010

Woodall American History X


American History X points out that there is a certain demographic that is attracted to such a group as the white supremacist neo-Nazis, and that is young, bullied, white males. The white supremacists offer a community for these harassed, confused teens and provide them with protection, friends, and a sense of belonging. These young boys become very susceptible to the ideology of the organization because of their respect for the veteran members who treated them with dignity. Danny Vineyard says that the “frustrated kids, the ones who were sick of getting their asses kicked by the black and Mexican gangs. [They] don’t just [want to] be some punk, [they want to] be a part of something.” The scene that depicts this the best is Derek’s speech before he and a group of young neo-Nazi members attack the Korean grocery store.

First, the use of black and white helps blend all the colors into different shades of white, black, and grey, so that all the subordinate characters lose individual identity and can only be considered neo-Nazis. To the young, impressionable teens that make up most of the group, this identity is better than not having an identity at all, which is how they felt prior to joining the group. Also, the dominant contrast throughout the entire scene is Derek, an intelligent, articulate, fearless man who shows compassion for the younger members. He serves as a father figure for these misguided boys who are looking for a strong role model to look up to. By serving as the dominant contrast throughout the scene, the director is demonstrating Derek’s image to the new members as a role model. In an article about white supremacy in film, Laura and Peter Finley state that, “the choice of which character is given the loudest, longest, and most passionate voice or opportunity to speak, makes a difference in the messages that viewers take from a film.” In this particular scene, Derek takes the vast majority of the face time showing just how important of a figure he is to the young teens who make up most of the members of the neo-Nazi group, and how his beliefs leave a lasting impression on the young minds of the teenagers in his group. Finally, character placement shows how such a group of impressionable teens are attracted to such an organization. In the scene, all the characters aside from Derek, his girlfriend, and Danny are in a tightly formed, intimate group. They are not alone anymore, but instead are in a close group of people like themselves. They also have the role model each teen has been yearning for. Derek is set a part from the group in the same way a preacher stands in front of a congregation while preaching. The group of common members reveres him, so he is made an individual a part from the rest of the group. The director keeps him at more of a personal and social distance from the rest of the group.

Brennan American History X

The scene which stood out the most to me as a scene which showed how a group of young people are attracted to this idea of Facism and Naziism is the scene at the basketball court. The scene is one of Danny's earliest memories of his brother's extreme pro-white ideals and actions. The scene, since it is a flashback, is filmed in black and white, like many other flashbacks throughout the film. The scene shows how dedicated Derek is to his (well, Cameron's) cause. The camera follows Derek and his teammates up and down the court during the match between the blacks and whites. Derek is the main person of interest, or the dominant, in this scene, because the entire idea is his thinking. The black and white film doesn't allow the audience members to clearly identify the different races; the two seem to blend in until Derek decides to segregate the teams. The background music also makes this competition seem more important and more warlike than it actually is. Also, the camera goes from filming the actual game to filming the crowd's response to different plays in the game. The slow motion filming shows Derek and the main Crip against each other, and allows for emotional appeal.
This scene specifically targets the younger people because it focuses on a sport and how competition is a way of settling arguments. It is easy to see, after watching this scene, how a group of young kids could fall into this disgraceful attitude and way of living. When older individuals like Cameron, and young adults like Derek and his girlfriend egg this behavior on, it is hard not to say yes. The article states that blacks are depicted as thugs, drug dealers, violent criminals in many films. The specific African Americans in this scene fit this stereotype, allowing Derek and his followers to have a "reason" to dislike them. They ruin the neighborhood where these young whites grew up. The Crips also egg the Whites on by calling them names and shoving them, showing that it was their fault in the first place, making the Whites' action seem justifiable.

Farris American History X


Neo-Nazism is depicted throughout American History X as a means of self-identification for lower-class white groups who feel victimized as if their own personal freedoms are being limited because of the influx of minority groups into any given area, as suggested by Finley's article. In the movie, it is also suggested that broken family structures can also lead to becoming involved with such a group, because younger members searching for the ideal "family" feel comforted in this group atmosphere. The scene in American History X that best illustrates how a person from a "broken family" would be attracted to Neo-Nazism is the dinner scene in which Derek and Danny's mother invites her new boyfriend over for the first time. A political discussion ensues, which becomes extremely heated in a matter of seconds. Derek is hostile towards this man because he feels as if he is trying to replace his father. Derek's entire goal while arguing was to violently combat everything that this man suggested no matter what, in order to intimidate him. The color values used in this scene play an extremely important part. The scene is in black and white, which actually causes the viewer to focus on the violence without worrying about other details. The intimate camera proxemics and tight framing used around each character in the scene cause audiences to look deep into the character's minds to examine what they are really thinking.

Bone American History X

The scene that proves this lost teenage, looking to fit in and belong, phrase in a young person’s life is the scene with the gang meeting up before they destroy the grocery store. The scene starts with Derek talk to Cameron about what the plan is, and Derek is illustrated as a puppet to be a leader to young people. Derek is seen almost like a patriarchal figure with his girlfriend and little brother by his side. Derek is the dominant in the scene. The lighting is in intense black and white which causes Derek to stand out even more with his white shirt and shaved head. The juxtaposition of the white against the black of the night causes viewers to listen to Derek just like the lost teens. This gives the other people the impression that he is a father or power figure. The pep talk before the actually destroying of the store is what is important. He tells them why they are doing this and how they need to take action on the store. He gets the young people to agree with him about why the store deserves to be looted. The camera proxemics is at a social distance.

The article on White Supremacy states “ Movies are for entertainment however…they circulate ideologies-about good and evil, order and disorder.” The article also makes us realize that even though the movie tries to depict the wrongs about racism they really “reinforce their worldview and perpetuate the racism they claim they want to reveal.”

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Rayburn American History X



One of the biggest points in the article was that anti-racist films paint a picture of a stereotypical "racist", making it easier for the viewer to remove the self from the equation and establish a clear "them" and "me". "Me" is not a racist because "me" is not like "them", the people being portrayed on the screen. The scene with the basketball game is one that most aptly illustrates this idea, and also makes nazism attractive to a class of young people.

The most noticeable element is color: the scene is in black and white. These periodic black and white scenes are the signals to how the people in the scene are thinking. They are thinking in black and white: you are black, I am white, we are completely different and cannot possibly get along and there is nothing else to it.

Character proxemics are also an important factor. The camera focuses mainly on two characters: Derek and a black character who has been set up to be his nemesis. Derek is portrayed as a strong white man who giving blacks a chance to "earn their keep", so to speak. The viewer's closeness to Derek and his opposer turn a small battle onto the basketball court into something clearly much bigger. It becomes a metaphor for the way racists justify their opinions. To Derek, blacks have been given their chance to make advancements to their livelihood, and haven't taken full advantage. This mimics the argument that almost all racists profess, and was also mentioned in the article.

The scene appeals to lower middle class youth in this way. The viewer is able to see these opinions played out in a way that is both relatable and not threatening, which is a very dangerous combination. Though this movie is anti-racist, many of the techniques cause the viewer to sometimes sympathize a little too much with Derek's mind.


McGowan American History X


One of the scenes that really stood out to me in American History X is the scene on the basketball court. I thought this scene did a great job illustrating the definition of white supremacy. It involves Derek challenging a few black guys to a game of basketball. This game is a battle to gain the basketball court territory. Derek is extremely confident with this game and comes through in the end. Throughout the scene, I noticed that it very much portrayed the black guys in a negative way. This scene definitely supports the article on white supremacy. The article often stated that black people are often portrayed in a negative way on screen. In this case, the white guys seemed to really be on their game while the black guys were running around like a bunch of ignorant monkeys. One of the black guys elbowed Derek in the face which is a sure portrayal of bad conduct. I think the fact that it was not the other way around is an important detail. In fact, the same black guys in the scene are the ones that try to steal Derek's car and get killed as a result.

I think that the type of people who are attracted to the white supremacy movement are ignorant. A huge problem in this subculture seems to be the fact that they are extremist for the sake of being extremist. Many of them have probably been offended by one or two minorities in their life time. However, the fact that someone could hate an entire race because of a couple of people is absolutely far fetched and ridiculous. It also seems to be the type of people who like being pissed off because they think it is badass.

One of the things that I noticed specifically about this scene is that at certain moments the camera would flash other stills from throughout the scene in fast motion. It seems to be coming from Derek's mind, in my opinion. These flashbacks from the scene seem to illustrate Derek's adrenaline rush. It makes me feel as if Derek is having a good time battling for the courts. I also noticed that there were quite a few close ups on the black leader's face. Every time, he had a horribly mean look on his face. Another important shot was at the end of the scene as the other whites are lifting Derek in victory. The camera is far below him and seems to look up at him in awe. He seems to smirk at the world in his blind victory and hatred.

Monday, November 1, 2010

McCay American History X Blog Prompt


American History X makes Facism/Nazism attractive to one class of young people. Choose a scene that illustrates that idea, and analyze it using mise en scene. You must also reference the White Supremacy article I have posted on Blackboard.